Форум Новости Космонавтики

Информация => Информация => Тема начата: David Lee Rickman от 02.11.2007 22:54:56

Название: Salyut 2, 3, or 5 on Proton (was TKS Image)
Отправлено: David Lee Rickman от 02.11.2007 22:54:56
Since this group was so successful at finding the TKS photo, I have another mystery photo which I will post here...

(http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2184/1827165482_b1650210d9_o.jpg)

This came from the same poster of images in the background of NK photo which showed "Almaz Reunion". It is of one of the Almaz stations designated Salyut 2, 3, or 5 on the Proton Carrier Rocket at the pad before launching.. Can anyone recognize this photo and help me find a better copy :wink: ???

(P.S. I edited the original image so the page would not have to extend so far to the right :wink: )
Название: Salyut 2, 3, or 5 on Proton (was TKS Image)
Отправлено: Вадим Лукашевич от 02.11.2007 16:01:06
Я так понимаю, Дэвид методично пойдет по каждой фотографии на этом плакате! :wink:
Название: Salyut 2, 3, or 5 on Proton (was TKS Image)
Отправлено: David Lee Rickman от 03.11.2007 00:44:35
ЦитироватьЯ так понимаю, Дэвид методично пойдет по каждой фотографии на этом плакате! :wink:

Alas, it is fortunate that this is the last. I have copies of all the other photographs represented on the poster (and a few more :wink: ) Some are in standard quality, while others are high resolution scans.

It is my passion (even obsession) to study the construction designs of Vladimir Chelomei and his design bureau. Much as an admirer of Rembrandt or Picasso may get a better appreciation for the artist by studying a painting with a magnifying glass to see every brush stroke, I study the photographs of this hardware to find every seam, rivet, and weld.

And since it is currently impossible for me to travel to the facilities of NPO Mash (or to the past to see the actual process) I seek out every photograph, drawing, or frame film footage I can find. So, now perhaps you can understand why it is that when I see a small blurry image it presents a challenge. It is evidence that there is yet another image which I have yet to examine.

We all have our different talents and desires. This is who I am, and this is what I do. I enjoy it very much, and I am quite fortunate to live in a time when such things have opened up and such communications are possible.

And I thank all who participate and add to my knowledge!
Название: Salyut 2, 3, or 5 on Proton (was TKS Image)
Отправлено: ronatu от 03.11.2007 09:43:11
(https://img.novosti-kosmonavtiki.ru/4663.jpg)
Название: Salyut 2, 3, or 5 on Proton (was TKS Image)
Отправлено: David Lee Rickman от 03.11.2007 13:31:18
Actually, I'm going to narrow this down and say this is NOT the Almaz designated Salyut-5. Without seeing the forward manuevering engine area clearer I can't tell if this is Salyut-2, or Salyut-3, but I will say it is not Salyut-5.
Название: Salyut 2, 3, or 5 on Proton (was TKS Image)
Отправлено: Александр Геннадьевич Шлядинский от 03.11.2007 13:51:02
Цитировать(https://img.novosti-kosmonavtiki.ru/4663.jpg)

Это из видеокосмосовского альбома "Орбитальный комплекс "МИР" 1986-2001". Там есть еще мои рисунки. Только меня в авторы забыли включить, о чем потом долго извинялись.
Название: Salyut 2, 3, or 5 on Proton (was TKS Image)
Отправлено: David Lee Rickman от 03.11.2007 23:57:30
ЦитироватьЭто из видеокосмосовского альбома "Орбитальный комплекс "МИР" 1986-2001". Там есть еще мои рисунки. Только меня в авторы забыли включить, о чем потом долго извинялись.

Yes, I remember. Shortly after this book was released I had my first meeting with the Head of Videocosmos, Vladimir Semenov. During this meeting I was presented with a copy of "Орбитальный комплекс "МИР" 1986-2001". Vladimir quickly pointed out that you had created these drawings, but in their error they had forgotten to include your name. He is a good man and was genuinely apologetic.
Название: Salyut 2, 3, or 5 on Proton (was TKS Image)
Отправлено: David Lee Rickman от 04.11.2007 03:56:03
I'm going to go out on a limb here and put my sleuthing abilities to the test. Based on what I can see in this image I am going to say that this is the Salyut-2/Almaz OPS-1

(http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2116/1844775930_3416dabfc4_o.jpg)

Any challenges to my assessment? Hopefully, with the help of this group, we will be able to locate a better copy of this image and see if I am correct.

Best Regards,
David L. Rickman
Название: Salyut 2, 3, or 5 on Proton (was TKS Image)
Отправлено: Вадим Лукашевич от 04.11.2007 11:38:19
Цитировать
ЦитироватьЭто из видеокосмосовского альбома "Орбитальный комплекс "МИР" 1986-2001". Там есть еще мои рисунки. Только меня в авторы забыли включить, о чем потом долго извинялись.
Yes, I remember. Shortly after this book was released I had my first meeting with the Head of Videocosmos, Vladimir Semenov. During this meeting I was presented with a copy of "Орбитальный комплекс "МИР" 1986-2001". Vladimir quickly pointed out that you had created these drawings, but in their error they had forgotten to include your name. He is a good man and was genuinely apologetic.
Да, проблемы с памятью там налицо! Вот еще один пример - когда я приобрел некоторые видеоматериалы по "Бурану" у "Видеокосмоса", В.Семенов обещал при первом же своем приезде в Москву передать мне письменную лицензию, подтверждающую мои права на их использование. С тех пор прошло уже 3 года, но лицензии, понятное дело, до сих пор нет.
Название: Salyut 2, 3, or 5 on Proton (was TKS Image)
Отправлено: David Lee Rickman от 04.11.2007 23:49:31
ЦитироватьДа, проблемы с памятью там налицо! Вот еще один пример - когда я приобрел некоторые видеоматериалы по "Бурану" у "Видеокосмоса", В.Семенов обещал при первом же своем приезде в Москву передать мне письменную лицензию, подтверждающую мои права на их использование. С тех пор прошло уже 3 года, но лицензии, понятное дело, до сих пор нет.

Yes, I've heard the mail delivery in Russian can be like that!  :lol:  :lol:  :lol:  :wink:
Название: Salyut 2, 3, or 5 on Proton (was TKS Image)
Отправлено: Лютич от 05.11.2007 19:15:14
I think it's not Salyut-2, because it was launched from different pad and it had slightly differnet colour scheme (dark line along the whole station)

You can see Salyut-2 in Мировая пилотируемая космонавтика? page 207
Название: Salyut 2, 3, or 5 on Proton (was TKS Image)
Отправлено: David Lee Rickman от 06.11.2007 03:30:18
ЦитироватьI think it's not Salyut-2, because it was launched from different pad and it had slightly differnet colour scheme (dark line along the whole station)

You can see Salyut-2 in Мировая пилотируемая космонавтика? page 207

I would love to see this image, but I have not yet been able to obtain this book. Salyut-2 and Salyut-3 did have slightly different paint schemes, but the dark colour on the front (top at launch) compartment was the radiator and was common on all three Almaz stations (Salyut- 2, 2, and 5).  Thier distinction would be around the forward manuevuering thruster area.  Salyut-2 was all dark in this area while Salyut-3 and 5 were white on the port and starboard sides. Can you scan and post the image you are referring to???
Название: Salyut 2, 3, or 5 on Proton (was TKS Image)
Отправлено: 0-Y-0 от 12.11.2007 03:18:47
Let's have a look. We'll see.
Название: Salyut 2, 3, or 5 on Proton (was TKS Image)
Отправлено: David Lee Rickman от 12.11.2007 11:49:02
ЦитироватьLet's have a look. We'll see.

Thank you. I would be grateful.
Название: Salyut 2, 3, or 5 on Proton (was TKS Image)
Отправлено: Лютич от 15.11.2007 14:43:27
Unfortunately I don't have any scanner at hand, so I had to use iSight camera

(http://img212.imageshack.us/img212/6897/75455380rj7.th.png) (http://img212.imageshack.us/my.php?image=75455380rj7.png)
Название: Salyut 2, 3, or 5 on Proton (was TKS Image)
Отправлено: David Lee Rickman от 15.11.2007 23:31:29
ЦитироватьUnfortunately I don't have any scanner at hand, so I had to use iSight camera

That's okay. The image is clear enough to compare it to other images which confirm that this is the Salyut-2/Almaz OPS-1

(https://img.novosti-kosmonavtiki.ru/4728.jpg)

Thank you very much for your help in identifying this image.

David L. Rickman